The Election That Keeps on Giving
BySome notes I scribbled down over the weekend about the election. It’s a little colder now, but I think the sentiment remains the same:
The euphoria over the election of Barack Hussein Obama as the 44th President of the United States of America may have died down, but there remains a feeling—on the street, in people’s homes, in cafes and bars—that this momentous event is still percolating through society and will continue to do so for months, probably years, to come.
I live in a predominantly black neighborhood in Brooklyn, on the border of Crown Heights, scene of a race riot in 1991, and Prospect Heights, a small, rapidly-gentrifying area where just a couple of generations ago few whites would consider living.
Today, black, white, gay, straight, Jew and gentile co-exist as well as any group of people living on top of each other can. Obama’s election did little to change the geniality that characterizes daily life in many of Brooklyn’s vibrant, multiethnic communities. But it certainly changed the way I, as a white, Jewish, British immigrant, perceive, and feel proud for, my black neighbors.
On November 4 and 5, the joy over Obama’s election could be heard in the shouts and car horns echoing down our block, seen in the newspaper and magazine headlines that trumpeted a historic victory the next day, and sensed in the unusually good mood that seemed to envelop most New Yorkers for the rest of the week. It was as though the Yankees had won the World Series and the entire city was a fan.
A couple of weeks on, and that sense of victory can still be felt, whether it be a celebratory toast at a party or a snippet of conversation overheard in the street. New Yorkers have a much greater tendency to talk to each other than Londoners. And traveling home on the 2 subway train the other day, I overheard a Hispanic girl complement a black female passenger who was wearing a large pin with a picture of the Obamas above the slogan “Africa’s First Family.” Her compliment was a simple as “I like your pin.” Yet it implied “I’m with you, too.”
The last stop on the 2 line in Manhattan is Wall Street, a neighborhood that is in desperate need of “hope” and “change” and a “yes, we can” attitude. As the train rumbles into Brooklyn, white passengers disembark in the upscale neighborhoods of Brooklyn Heights and Park Slope. By the time it reaches my stop, at Eastern Parkway-Brooklyn Museum, the white exodus is almost complete save for perhaps a few white students who have opted for the cheaper rents of Crown Heights.
As a white passenger it is hard not to look at the faces of your fellow black commuters—students and workers, mothers and fathers—and wonder what it means for them and their children that after so many generations of inequality and oppression, a black man is headed for the White House? How would they have felt if, as many had quietly feared, white voters had deserted the black candidate in the privacy of the polling booth? Does it mean anything to them that more white men and women voted for Barack Obama in 2008 than John Kerry in 2004?
After exiting the train I make my way down Washington Avenue, a disheveled thoroughfare lined with shabby bodegas and peppered with numerous barber shops and hair braiding salons, Caribbean restaurants and a check cashing office. The weather is still mild enough for people to continue the summer habit of congregating on the pavement, many sitting on fold out chairs and engaged in animated conversation.
I don’t feel any more welcome weaving between them in the dawn of the age of Obama than I did last month. After all, I am still a gentrifier, a yuppie whose very presence threatens to perpetuate the steady influx of young whites to the area and to continue to drive up real estate prices and rents. But I do feel as though the gap between us has narrowed. For all they know I could have been one of the millions of white Americans who manned phone banks or fanned out across polling stations, who pulled the lever or pushed the button that helped put Barack Obama where he is today.
For if the simple act of electing a man can only go so far in healing the wounds of slavery and segregation, it does at least prove one thing. That in the space of a little under a couple of years, America has undergone a momentous change.
9 Comments
November 19th, 2008 at 8:50 pm
When we first moved here in 2003 we lived in Harlem and stayed for a few years. Apart of me longed to be back in that apartment on 120th street on Election night to just be a part of history. Or even to have been back in the classroom to have been teaching during this election. But the best thing happened – the morning after the election I started getting all these messages on Facebook from my former students that I taught in 2004 and 2005 – saying that they remembered that I told them to keep an eye on Obama and that I had told them that he could possibly be the first black president.
November 21st, 2008 at 10:23 am
Hopefully someday you will also feel proud as a man looking at the 52% women around you – that day when we have a female president!
November 21st, 2008 at 5:41 pm
I don’t want to be too critical. I think you’re a good writer and I’ve enjoyed a lot of your stuff.
But fuck this is an embarrasing post. A strange mixture of fawning and condescension with overtones of guilt.
To get this excited about the election of a pure Chicago machine politician ? You might look back at this in a few years and wince.
Anyway enjoy your (non-political) stuff.
November 21st, 2008 at 5:59 pm
“You might look back at this in a few years and wince.”
He might. If he turns into a twat.
November 21st, 2008 at 7:55 pm
Or if he realises that black people are grown ups and there is no need to feel guilty about being a ‘yuppie gentrifier’ in ‘their neighbourhoods’ or proud for them.
November 21st, 2008 at 8:57 pm
So you shouldn’t feel empathy towards adults? Towards different groups of people? And you shouldn’t feel pride for other people? Is he allowed to feel pride for gay people if they get marriage rights or is that too fawning? Would he be allowed to feel pride for women if Hillary had been elected, or would that be patronizing to women? Have you ever tried to imagine what it might be like to be a black person in America? And if you have, how could you possibly have felt anything but pride on election night? How does one become so cynical? “a pure Chicago machine politician ?” Unbelievable.
November 21st, 2008 at 9:48 pm
Empathise away. I imagine you could feel happy for them. Proud ? Not really the word I would use unless I felt superior to them.
And to answer the question – yes it would be patronising to women to feel proud that some of them had voted for someone of their own sex in an election. Not really an achievement is it ?
Obama isn’t a machine politician ?
ballot challenges ? divorce court leaks ? Rezko ? Do you know any of this stuff?
I think it was a reasonable choice to vote for Obama , but let’s not turn the guy into something he isn’t.
Shame, guilt and condescension. Great mix.
November 21st, 2008 at 11:00 pm
Isn’t empathizing sharing the feelings of others? If others feel pride and you empathize with them… wouldn’t you feel, erm, pride?
“…let’s not turn the guy into something he isn’t”
Couldn’t agree more, which is why I’ll ignore your dire view of him.
November 22nd, 2008 at 12:10 pm
Simon, not that it’s going to change your mind but I would like to clarify one point.
I think there is a difference between being “proud of” someone and being “proud for” someone.
To be “proud of” my neighbors in this context would, I agree, be patronizing.
But I wrote that I felt “proud for” my neighbors. As in, I felt their pride. And that, I believe, is akin to Cretin’s empathy.